Comments on: Power of Schmooze Award http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/ A Christian Blog about Christian Apologetics Mon, 01 Mar 2010 17:30:19 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Gina Dalfonzo http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/comment-page-1/#comment-105 Gina Dalfonzo Tue, 09 Oct 2007 20:05:54 +0000 http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/#comment-105 Just saw this post (I'm a little slow sometimes). Thank you for the honor! :-) Just saw this post (I’m a little slow sometimes). Thank you for the honor! :-)

]]> By: Richard Smolenski http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/comment-page-1/#comment-82 Richard Smolenski Fri, 05 Oct 2007 02:14:43 +0000 http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/#comment-82 [quote comment="81"] Are you implying that Catholics aren't Christians in this statement?[/quote] Not at all. Just like not everyone who goes to a Christian church is a "Christian," neither is everyone who goes to a Catholic church. As a group, though, I cannot say that all <em>Catholics</em> are <em>Christians</em> because, based upon my time in the Catholic church, not all of them are. [quote comment="81"]

Are you implying that Catholics aren’t Christians in this statement?[/quote]

Not at all. Just like not everyone who goes to a Christian church is a “Christian,” neither is everyone who goes to a Catholic church. As a group, though, I cannot say that all Catholics are Christians because, based upon my time in the Catholic church, not all of them are.

]]> By: tiber jumper http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/comment-page-1/#comment-81 tiber jumper Fri, 05 Oct 2007 01:31:04 +0000 http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/#comment-81 "Maybe becoming a Catholic wasn’t right and I question his reason for it, but his contributions to moral and ethical issues are still relevant to Christians." Are you implying that Catholics aren't Christians in this statement? “Maybe becoming a Catholic wasn’t right and I question his reason for it, but his contributions to moral and ethical issues are still relevant to Christians.”

Are you implying that Catholics aren’t Christians in this statement?

]]> By: Richard Smolenski http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/comment-page-1/#comment-80 Richard Smolenski Wed, 03 Oct 2007 05:28:55 +0000 http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/#comment-80 Ed, I can't think of how anything I have read that he has written regarding social issues does not fit into a Protestant worldview. Nothing I learned in the graduate course that I took from him a few years ago would differ now. We also spoke after he invited me to contact him regarding <a href="http://www.prudentmusings.com/christianity/francis-beckwith-a-catholic/" rel="nofollow">this post</a> and I'm contemplating Baylor again after I finish up my M.Div. In addition, I have no fears regarding the possibility of increased apologetic engagement between the two groups. I left Catholicism many years ago, but unlike Dr. Beckwith, I have no plans of going back. Ed,

I can’t think of how anything I have read that he has written regarding social issues does not fit into a Protestant worldview. Nothing I learned in the graduate course that I took from him a few years ago would differ now. We also spoke after he invited me to contact him regarding this post and I’m contemplating Baylor again after I finish up my M.Div.

In addition, I have no fears regarding the possibility of increased apologetic engagement between the two groups.

I left Catholicism many years ago, but unlike Dr. Beckwith, I have no plans of going back.

]]> By: Ed http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/comment-page-1/#comment-79 Ed Wed, 03 Oct 2007 03:34:55 +0000 http://www.prudentmusings.com/blogging/power-of-schmooze-award/#comment-79 Just curious - did you mean that Beckwith's contributions to moral and ethical issues are still relevant to Protestants? Or did you mean to say Christians? Is there any reason anything he's written WOULDN'T still be relevant to all Christians. Wondered if you knew that he's been out there on the stump encouraging Catholics to explore the best Protestant apologists and theologians. I know you ONLY were meaning to compliment, but often the most interesting thoughts are those lurking under the surface :) Just curious – did you mean that Beckwith’s contributions to moral and ethical issues are still relevant to Protestants? Or did you mean to say Christians? Is there any reason anything he’s written WOULDN’T still be relevant to all Christians.

Wondered if you knew that he’s been out there on the stump encouraging Catholics to explore the best Protestant apologists and theologians.

I know you ONLY were meaning to compliment, but often the most interesting thoughts are those lurking under the surface :)

]]>